When is a contract not a contract?

Wilson Browne

1st May 2019

Legal Briefing

Wilson Browne

By David Farmer


Wilson Browne Solicitors

MOST people will be aware of the tragic accident of Emiliano Sala, the Cardiff City striker, who died in a plane crash on 21 January, when the light aircraft in which he was travelling plunged into the English Channel.

The tragedy raises interesting questions and inevitable financial squabbles as Cardiff City had agreed to pay Nantes the sum of £15m for the player - an agreement that would have been recorded in a written contract. Now, there are questions raised about the validity of the contract.

Obviously, we have not seen the contract but it has been reported that the first instalment of over £5m has not been paid by Cardiff City to Nantes and many people will be asking themselves whether the contract remains valid.

Let's consider some of the issues that arise when terminating a contract and what gives a party the right to do so.

When looking at whether a party has the right to terminate, the party wishing to terminate must first communicate that it has decided to bring it to an end.

Repudiatory Breach

A repudiatory breach is one that is so serious that it entitles the 'innocent' party to bring the contract to an end and to recover damages, and is a common law right that exists alongside the contractual terms (of a contract). It is important to understand the conditions of a contract when looking to see if a repudiatory breach has occurred. A condition is a vital term of a contract whereas a warranty is classed as a minor one. An innominate term is halfway between the two. In practice, unless a term is defined as a condition or warranty it will be seen as an innominate term.

A repudiatory breach can occur in three ways.

1. The first is that a party cannot perform its obligations or has refused to do so.

2. There has been a breach of a condition of the contract. If there has been a breach, no matter how small, then the innocent party can terminate.

3. A breach of what is called an intermediate or innominate term. This breach must be serious or go to the root of the contract to enable the party to end the contract.

A breach of warranty will not give rise to the right to repudiate a contract, but a repudiatory breach does, and needs to be communicated to the party in breach. Written form is always best as it removes any ambiguity.

Or, the 'innocent' party can decide to just carry on: this means that damages cannot be claimed for loss, but it may be in the 'innocent' party's interest to demand performance/delivery of the contract.

Once the notice has been given then it cannot be withdrawn: think carefully about giving notice as it cannot be unilaterally withdrawn, but equally, act in a timely fashion otherwise the right to terminate can be lost.

Contractual Breach

Contracts often contain clauses that define how a contract may be brought to an end. Some contracts will define what a condition of the contract is and what a warranty is. Others may refer to the right to terminate a contract for material or substantial breaches.

Sometimes a party may have a right to exercise both a repudiatory breach or a contractual breach, in which case consider which route you are taking and why (eg if it is decided to exercise a breach of contractual terms then you may lose a right to claim loss of profits).

But wait, there's more.

There are other methods which we will touch upon:

* Rescission: Where a party enters into a contract based on false information.

* Mistake: If a mistake has been made when entering into a contract eg the identity of the parties entering into the contract being wrong.

* Frustration: Extreme events, such as an outbreak of war.


It's complex! Our best advice is - get professional advice.

As for whether Cardiff City is required to pay £5m for the player they never got, no doubt that will be for the courts to decide.

For more information, contact Wilson Browne Solicitors on 0800 088 6004 or visit www.wilsonbrowne.co.uk